I recently got the Lorac Front of the Line Pro Eye Pencils in Antique Gold, Teal, and Rose Bronze. The three of them came in a bundle called Take me to Tantego and my sister got them for me at Nordstrom for only $15.
And I am so glad to say they are the best eyeliners I’ve ever tried! I’ve used all shades several ways already: as an eyeshadow base, on my upper and lower waterline, and on my lashline; all three of them performed exceptionally well. I didn’t experience skipping or transfer. I was able to smudge them with no problem for 30s to a minute before it set completely. I had no issue smoking it out or building it up, I also had no issues winging it with an eyeliner brush. I wore them all for a full day and even though I have watery eyes, I experienced no transfer! As an eyeshadow base, it intensifies the color on top and also makes the eyeshadow last longer.
They also each come with their own sharpeners which makes it incredibly convenient to keep them sharp and sanitary. They’re also sturdy enough to sharpen without breaking but creamy enough to apply with a light amount of pressure. I love them so much and I would love to collect all the shades!
Hope this helps, and until next time!